Send an Inquiry
Power Protection Relays

22kV Protection Relays for Substation and Distribution Feeders

Table of Contents

What protection functions do 22kV substation relays need?

A 22kV protection relay measures current and voltage on one circuit, decides whether it is a fault and trips the breaker that clears it. One substation rarely uses one relay type: incomers, transformers, feeders and busbars each need a different function set, so selection starts from the single-line diagram. The defining detail at 22kV is earthing. The network is usually resistance-earthed or resonant-earthed rather than solidly earthed, so earth-fault current is deliberately limited and 50N/51N must be set against that limit, not against the phase fault level. That single difference separates 22kV practice from both 11kV distribution and the solidly earthed arrangements on many 33kV systems, and it is the setting most often copied wrongly between projects. Device numbers follow ANSI/IEEE C37.2-2022; performance follows IEC 60255-151:2009 (overcurrent), IEC 60255-127:2010 (voltage), IEC 60255-181:2019 (frequency) and IEC 60255-187-1:2021 (differential). Instrument transformer limits follow IEC 61869-2:2012 and IEC 61869-3:2011. Setting review and quotation within 12 hours, MOQ 1, 7-15 working days.

A 22kV protection relay measures current and voltage on one 22kV substation circuit, decides whether the reading is a fault, and trips the breaker that clears it. One substation rarely uses one relay type throughout: incomers, transformers, feeders and busbars each need a different function set, so 22kV protection relay selection starts from the single-line diagram.

At a Glance: What a 22kV Protection Relay Covers

  • 50/51 phase overcurrent: phase-to-phase faults, set above load and below minimum fault
  • 50N/51N earth fault: single-phase-to-earth current, set by the grounding resistor or coil
  • 87 differential: internal transformer or busbar faults, needs matched CTs at every boundary
  • 27/59 voltage: undervoltage on motor busbars, overvoltage from ferroresonance or load rejection
  • 81 frequency: load shedding and islanding detection on weak incoming supplies
  • 67/67N directional: ring or parallel feeders where fault current reverses
  • 49 thermal: transformer and cable overload that does not reach fault magnitude
  • 50BF breaker failure: back-up tripping when the assigned breaker does not open

A 22kV substation sits between distribution and transmission practice in one specific way: the network is usually resistance-earthed or resonant-earthed rather than solidly earthed, so earth-fault current is deliberately limited and 50N/51N has to be set against that limit instead of against the phase fault level. That single difference separates 22kV substation protection from both 11kV distribution practice and the solidly earthed arrangements found on many 33kV systems. It is also the setting that gets copied wrongly between projects most often.

22kV protection relay installed in a 22kV substation switchgear panel (illustrative)

Function numbers follow ANSI/IEEE C37.2-2022. Performance requirements for the individual functions come from the IEC 60255 series: IEC 60255-151:2009 for over/under current, IEC 60255-127:2010 for over/under voltage, IEC 60255-181:2019 for frequency, and IEC 60255-187-1:2021 for differential. Instrument transformer limits come from IEC 61869-2:2012 (current) and IEC 61869-3:2011 (voltage).

The sections below move in the order an engineer actually works: which circuits need protection, what each relay measures, how CT and VT data restrict the choice, how grounding fixes the earth-fault setting, and what to send a supplier. The last section is a checklist you can paste into an enquiry.

Circuits that need protection

Most 22kV substations need protection on four circuit categories.

CircuitPrimary concernTypical relay functions
Incoming circuitsSystem faults, backup50/51, 50N/51N, 27/59
Outgoing feedersPhase and ground faults50/51, 50N/51N, 79
TransformersInternal and external faults87T, 50/51, 50N/51N, 49
BusbarsInternal bus faults87B (where applicable)

Selecting a relay for a live project?

Send the system voltage, CT ratio and tripping scheme. Our engineers confirm the model and reply within 12 hours.

View relay modelsRequest a quote

The scheme differs by circuit because the fault behavior and the damage mechanisms differ. A transformer sees inrush current at energization; a feeder does not. A busbar fault affects several circuits at once. These differences drive the relay choice.

What a relay protects

A 22kV protection relay does not protect equipment directly. It measures the circuit, detects abnormal conditions, and issues a trip signal that opens the circuit breaker to isolate the faulted section.

CT/VT → protection relay → protection logic → trip signal → circuit breaker

Protection relay operation flow: measured input, logic evaluation, trip output (illustrative)

A relay with the right functions will still fail to protect the system if the CT ratio is wrong, the trip circuit cannot open the breaker, or the coordination settings are incorrect.

Six factors in relay selection

Substation relay selection turns on six inputs, and none of them is the voltage class on its own:

  • Equipment type: transformer, feeder, busbar, or motor
  • Network topology: radial, ring, or parallel
  • Grounding method: solid, resistance, or impedance
  • Fault level: available short-circuit current
  • Operating mode: normal, backup, or emergency
  • Coordination: grading with upstream and downstream devices

A radial feeder with a single source may need only overcurrent protection. The same feeder in a closed ring with several sources needs directional elements to clear faults correctly.

22kV Feeder Protection: Radial and Ring Buses

22kV feeder protection is where the topology decision becomes a relay decision. On a radial feeder with a single source, fault current only flows one way, so 50/51 with 50N/51N covers phase and earth faults and nothing else is needed. Close the ring or add a second source and the same feeder sees fault current from both directions, at which point a non-directional relay trips on faults it was never meant to clear.

  • Radial, single source: 50/51 phase plus 50N/51N earth fault, graded against the downstream device
  • Ring or parallel feeders: add 67 and 67N, polarised from VT or from memory voltage
  • Overhead sections: add 79 auto-reclose, because most faults are transient
  • Cable sections: no reclose, and 50N/51N sensitivity follows the earthing resistor rating
  • Feeders feeding a transformer: the feeder relay backs up the transformer relay, so check both curves against the same fault level

The check that catches most specification errors is the minimum fault current at the far end of the feeder. If the two-phase fault current at the remote end is below the 51 pickup, the element will not see it at all, and no amount of curve shaping fixes that. Run the minimum case before fixing the pickup. The wider selection sequence is set out in the guide to choosing a protection relay for a medium voltage substation.

Types of Protection Relays in a Power System

Overcurrent (50/51)

Instantaneous overcurrent (ANSI 50) and time overcurrent (ANSI 51) are the foundation of 22kV protection. They detect phase faults and can back up downstream devices.

Overcurrent is enough for radial feeders with a single source and coordinated grading with downstream fuses or relays. It needs support in ring or parallel systems, where fault current can flow either way. There a directional element (ANSI 67) supervises the overcurrent function to prevent tripping on reverse faults.

Earth fault (50N/51N)

Earth fault relays detect phase-to-ground faults by measuring residual current. The sensitivity required depends on the grounding method. Setting the pickup and the curve is where most grading errors start; see how to set an overcurrent protection relay correctly for the step sequence.

On 22kV systems the earthing method fixes the setting, and there are three common cases. With resistance earthing, the resistor limits single-phase earth fault current to a defined value, typically in the range of 200 A to 1000 A, and 50N/51N is set below that limit with a margin for the resistor tolerance. With resonant earthing through an arc-suppression coil, the residual current after compensation is often below 10 A, which is too small for a simple overcurrent element, so the scheme moves to a wattmetric or admittance based earth fault function or to a 59N displacement voltage alarm. On unearthed systems, 59N alarming is the usual arrangement and the first earth fault is located rather than tripped.

Solidly grounded systems produce high earth-fault current, so a standard residual connection from the three phase CTs gives enough sensitivity. Resistance-grounded and impedance-grounded systems limit the earth-fault current to lower values, and standard residual measurement may miss these faults. A core-balance CT (CBCT) around the three phases gives higher sensitivity for these applications.

The earth-fault scheme cannot be standardized across all 22kV systems. A relay suited to a solidly grounded substation may be inadequate for a resistance-grounded one.

Differential (87)

Differential relays compare current entering and leaving a protected zone. They catch faults that overcurrent protection cannot see clearly, mainly transformer internal faults and busbar faults.

Transformer differential (87T) compares the HV and MV currents and uses harmonic restraint to avoid operating on inrush. It is used where the speed and sensitivity of internal fault detection justify the extra CT and wiring. Busbar differential (87B) compares the currents on all circuits connected to a busbar, and is used where a bus fault would cause a wide outage or equipment damage.

Differential protection is not required at every 22kV substation. Whether it applies depends on the transformer rating, the busbar arrangement, and the protection philosophy.

Voltage (27/59)

Undervoltage (27) and overvoltage (59) relays monitor system voltage against configured thresholds. They apply where a voltage deviation indicates a fault or an abnormal condition, such as loss of supply on an incoming circuit or overvoltage from a disconnected load. The principle behind the biased comparison is covered in the differential relay protection guide.

Frequency (81)

Frequency relays (81U/81O) detect underfrequency and overfrequency. In 22kV distribution substations they are used selectively, usually where islanding detection or load-shedding coordination needs frequency monitoring.

Directional (67/67N)

Directional overcurrent relays measure current magnitude and direction, and operate only for faults in one direction. They prevent misoperation when fault current flows in reverse.

Directional protection is needed when the network has multiple sources, a closed ring, or parallel feeders where fault current can arrive from more than one direction. The voltage level alone does not decide this. A radial 22kV feeder does not need it; a closed-ring 22kV network does.

Choosing power protection relays for a 22kV substation

Choosing a 22kV protection relay comes down to seven questions, in this order.

1. What is the relay protecting?

Start with the protected equipment. A transformer needs differential protection that a feeder does not. A busbar needs zone-selective protection. The equipment type sets the core functions. Polarisation and the reverse-fault case are set out in the directional overcurrent protection article.

2. What faults must it detect?

EquipmentMain fault concernPossible protection
FeederPhase/ground fault50/51, 50N/51N
TransformerInternal/external fault87T, 50/51, 50N/51N
BusbarInternal bus fault87B
IncomingSystem/feeder fault50/51, 50N/51N, 27/59

This table gives the minimum function set. Additional functions depend on coordination and operating requirements.

3. How do CT and VT data affect the choice?

CT and VT specifications decide whether a relay will work. Confirm: Both have to match the 22kV protection relay input range, and a mismatch here is the most common reason a correctly specified scheme still misoperates.

  • CT ratio: must match the load and fault current range
  • CT class: a protection class such as 5P20 keeps accuracy during faults
  • CT secondary: 1 A or 5 A, matching the relay input
  • CT burden: total connected burden must stay within the CT capability
  • VT ratio and connection: star, delta, or open delta

The relay is not chosen from the voltage level alone. The CT/VT configuration is part of the selection, not an afterthought.

4. How does the grounding method affect the choice?

The grounding method sets the earth-fault current, which sets the sensitivity requirement.

  • Solidly grounded: high earth-fault current; standard residual CT connection is enough
  • Resistance grounded: limited earth-fault current; may need a sensitive earth-fault element
  • Impedance grounded or ungrounded: very low earth-fault current; CBCT or specialized sensitive protection

Specifying an earth-fault relay without confirming the grounding method is a common source of protection gaps.

5. How does coordination affect the choice?

A relay with the right functions is still unsuitable if its settings cannot achieve the coordination. Coordination requires:

  • Pickup current: must separate normal load from fault conditions
  • Time delay: must grade with upstream and downstream devices
  • Grading margin: covers CT errors, relay tolerances, and breaker time

A relay with a wide setting range and flexible time-current curves gives more coordination options than a fixed-characteristic device. When upstream and downstream devices come from different manufacturers, the relay’s ability to match IEC or ANSI curves becomes a practical criterion.

6. When is directional protection added?

Add directional elements when fault current can flow both ways through the relay location. This happens in closed-ring networks, parallel feeders with multiple sources, and incoming circuits where the utility can back-feed through the substation.

Not every 22kV circuit needs it. The network topology, not the voltage level, decides.

7. What communication and control functions are needed?

Modern relays communicate with SCADA and substation automation. Specify only the protocols the project needs:

  • RS485/Modbus: common for retrofit and smaller substations
  • Ethernet/IEC 61850: for digital substations and multi-vendor interoperability
  • DNP3 or IEC 60870-5-103: for utility SCADA

Confirm the control and trip outputs as well: the number of trip contacts, breaking capacity, auxiliary outputs, and binary inputs for status monitoring.

The relay inside the protection scheme

Power system protective relaying treats a relay as one part of a complete scheme, not an isolated device. A power protection relay cannot be chosen on its own.

protected equipment → CT/VT → protection relay → protection logic → circuit breaker → SCADA/control

Protection system signal chain from CT and VT through the relay to the breaker trip coil (illustrative)

IEC 60255-1:2022 defines measuring relays and protection equipment to include “any combination of equipment to form a distributed protection scheme for power system protection such as control, monitoring and process interface equipment.” The standard does not treat the relay as an isolated device.

For a 22kV specification, the 22kV protection relay cannot be chosen without confirming the CT and VT characteristics, breaker trip circuit compatibility, coordination settings, and communication interfaces.

CT, VT and Grading Limits

Three numbers decide whether a 22kV protection relay works on site, and none of them appear on the relay datasheet.

  • CT accuracy limit factor: the protection class has to cover the maximum fault current. A 5P20 CT stays within 5% composite error up to 20 times rated current; if the maximum three-phase fault current exceeds 20 times the CT primary rating, specify a higher ALF rather than accepting saturation. Metering classes such as 0.5 are not a substitute, because they saturate exactly when the relay needs them.
  • CT knee-point voltage: for differential schemes the knee-point voltage has to exceed the voltage the CT must develop into the total burden at maximum through-fault current, or the scheme loses stability on external faults.
  • Grading margin: leave 0.3 s to 0.4 s between the operating time of a downstream element and the upstream one. That margin covers breaker operating time, relay timing error and CT error, and it is the number that gets squeezed when someone wants faster upstream tripping.

The same grading rules apply one voltage class up, which is why the 33kV protection relay page reads so similarly, and the whole substation view is covered under the relay protection system of a factory substation. Pickup ratios follow the same logic: set the upstream pickup at roughly 1.2 to 1.3 times the downstream one so that the two curves never cross in the region where both devices see the same current.

Specifying relays for a project

Electrical data for the supplier

  • System voltage and rated current
  • Short-circuit level (maximum and minimum fault current)
  • CT ratio, class, and secondary rating
  • VT ratio and connection
  • Grounding method
  • Frequency
  • Single-line diagram

Protection functions

The table lists the main types of relays in power system protection and the ANSI codes to specify for power protection relays.

FunctionANSIApplication
Instantaneous overcurrent50Feeder, transformer backup
Time overcurrent51Feeder, transformer backup
Earth fault50N/51NAll circuits
Undervoltage27Incoming, busbar
Overvoltage59Incoming, busbar
Frequency81Selective
Breaker failure50BFCritical circuits
Reclosing79Overhead feeders
Directional overcurrent67Ring/parallel networks

Do not specify every available function just because the relay supports it. Each function adds configuration complexity and testing. Specify the functions the scheme needs.

Communication and panel integration

  • Communication protocol (IEC 61850, Modbus, DNP3)
  • Auxiliary supply voltage (110 V DC, 220 V DC, or AC)
  • Trip output contact rating and quantity
  • Alarm contact quantity
  • Mounting dimensions and terminal arrangement
  • SCADA interface

Testing and documentation before delivery

Request factory test reports covering:

  • Protection function testing (pickup, timing, characteristic curves)
  • Binary input/output verification
  • Communication protocol testing
  • Setting verification against the approved settings schedule

Per IEC 60255-1, type test reports should cover product safety, EMC, environmental, and functional tests. Where the relay includes IEC 61850 communication, conformance certificates give additional assurance of multi-vendor interoperability.

Supplier support

A supplier that understands 22kV protection can review the single-line diagram, match relay functions to the protected equipment, and confirm CT/VT compatibility before quotation. The workflow is:

customer SLD + electrical data → protection requirements review → relay function matching → technical confirmation → quotation

For project-specific configuration, the supplier should confirm the settings logic, communication mapping, and trip output assignments before production. Factory testing against the approved settings documents that the relay will operate as specified.

Checklist before ordering

CheckConfirm
Protected equipmentFeeder, transformer, busbar, or incoming
System voltage22kV nominal
Rated currentActual load and fault current range
Fault levelMaximum and minimum short-circuit current
CT ratio/class/secondaryMatch relay input
VT ratio/secondaryMatch relay voltage input
Grounding methodSets earth-fault sensitivity
Protection functionsRequired ANSI codes per circuit
CoordinationPickup and time grading with existing devices
Directional requirementBased on network topology
Communication protocolMatch SCADA/automation system
Auxiliary supplyAC or DC voltage rating
Trip output contactsQuantity and breaking capacity
Testing requirementsFAT scope and documentation
DocumentationDrawings, settings, test reports

FAQ

1. What is a 22kV protection relay used for in a substation?

They detect faults and abnormal conditions on feeders, transformers, incoming circuits, and busbars, then issue trip signals to open circuit breakers and isolate the faulted section.

2. What types of protection relays are used in a power system?

Overcurrent, earth fault, differential, voltage, frequency, and directional relays, chosen according to the protected equipment and the coordination requirements.

3. Is overcurrent protection enough for a 22kV feeder?

It depends on the network topology. Radial feeders with a single source can use overcurrent protection with proper grading. Ring or parallel systems need directional elements to avoid tripping on reverse faults.

4. When does a 22kV feeder need directional protection?

When fault current can flow both ways through the relay location, usually in closed-ring networks or parallel feeders with multiple sources.

5. Does every 22kV substation need differential protection?

No. Differential protection applies selectively to transformers and busbars where the speed and sensitivity of internal fault detection justify the extra CT and wiring.

6. Can one power protection relay replace all the others?

No. Different equipment needs different functions, measurement inputs, and logic. A transformer relay cannot stand in for a feeder relay.

7. How do CT and VT specifications affect relay selection?

CT ratio sets the measurable current range, CT class affects accuracy during faults, and VT configuration affects voltage measurement and directional polarization. Incorrect CT/VT matching is a common cause of misoperation.

8. What should I send a supplier when requesting power system protection relays?

A single-line diagram, CT/VT data, load current, fault level, grounding method, required protection functions, and communication requirements.

Conclusion

A 22kV protection relay is chosen from the protected equipment, the fault types, the grounding method, and the CT/VT and coordination data, not from the voltage level alone. Confirming the functions, CT/VT compatibility, and coordination before ordering avoids the most common protection gaps. The same principles of power system protective relaying apply across the field, from distribution substations to protective relaying for power generation systems.

Field record

The 22-35 kV band in our record covers a wide spread of facilities: a water treatment plant and a coal mine substation in Laos at 22-35 kV, a coastal resort and provincial grain storage in Cambodia, and a steel mill substation plus commercial district distribution in Thailand at 22-115 kV. At that voltage the relay set is usually overcurrent plus earth fault plus under-voltage. All of these are listed in the project record.

Technical References and Sources

SourceWhat it coversTypeEdition
ANSI/IEEE C37.2-2022Device function numbers for the functions discussed hereIEEE Standard2022
IEC 60255-1:2022General requirements for measuring relays and protection equipmentIEC Standard2022
IEC 60255-151:2009Functional requirements for over/under current protection (the 50/51 side)IEC Standard2009
IEC 60255-127:2010Functional requirements for over/under voltage protection (27/59)IEC Standard2010
IEC 60255-181:2019Functional requirements for frequency protection (81)IEC Standard2019
IEC 60255-187-1:2021Functional requirements for differential protection (87)IEC Standard2021
IEC 61869-2:2012Additional requirements for current transformersIEC Standard2012
IEC 61869-3:2011Additional requirements for inductive voltage transformersIEC Standard2011

Written by Leon Zhang, Protection Application Engineer. Technical review by the relayprotect.com engineering team. Last reviewed October 2026.

Questions on the settings in this guide go to the engineering team, normally answered the same working day.

22 kV protection devices used in these schemes: 87T transformer differential relay; 87B busbar differential relay; ASL-441H feeder protection relay.

About Author
Leon Zhang
Hello, I'm Leon Zhang. I have 15 years of experience in the power relay protection industry with extensive pre-sales and after-sales project experience. Our company specializes in various complete sets of relay protection and automation equipment. I can assist customers in solving all practical on-site project challenges and provide optimal integrated solutions.
Tell Us Your Requirement
Send an Inquiry

High Quality

Stable performance, reliable design, ensuring safe operation for power system protection and grid stability.

Fast Delivery

Timely delivery to support your urgent orders and project schedules efficiently and professionally at any time.

Best Warranty

Professional Warranty: Reliable after-sales support for stable relay protection and long-term customer satisfaction.